Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sam Byrd's avatar

My fingers alighted on the first full paragraph on p. 551. I told myself I would limit myself to one paragraph, and was surprised to see a relatively short one! It has to do with Mr. Spitzer hearing Cousin Hannah's death throes, "like music previously ignored." She's crying for her skirt, the skirt she "took off so long ago in a snow storm," perhaps the one her love disappeared in? The image of putting on her skirt "like the surf booming against the great, jagged rocks reaching through clouds" doesn't mean much to me. I may be too tired to appreciate this. Is the skirt a flashy peignoir-like white thing, spread out like waves crashing? I don't know. I feel like maybe the skirt was described earlier?

Expand full comment
Bill M's avatar

Hello! Thank you for doing this, it’s been great fun being able to see your reflections and conversation while reading through MMMD myself for the first time!

My passage came from page 334 - the paragraph beginning with “My mother would never tire of discussing her final obsequies…”. At first, having chosen at random, I enjoyed how prototypical this paragraph seemed for Miss Macintosh on the surface, with not quite half of the paragraph being composed of a list of various modes of travel and various breeds of dog!

From there I was led to reflect on the humor in how Young expresses herself here - Vera’s mother would never tire? She never leaves her bed! She may choose not to invite Mr. Spitzer? He is never invited but always arrives punctually, and her invited guests are usually figments!

From here I thought about Catherine’s position in life as we see it in the novel as almost an inverse of Vera’s journey on the bus. Vera in the constant motion of the moving vehicle reflecting on her childhood and observing the tangible sensible markers of the people around her (the clothing of the other passengers, their body language, voices), moving fast but taking much of it in as if a passive observer. While on the other hand her mother Catherine remains simply still in one place nearly unable to notice the things that she might tangibly sense in her vicinity, nevertheless she seems not passive at all in her mind but is always creating or composing colorful ideas of visitors at her bedside in great detail.

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts